01 · DiscoveryLook everywhere first
Every South American hotel in the MICHELIN Guide, Relais & Châteaux, SLH and LHW; the Forbes, World's 50 Best, Condé Nast Traveler and Travel + Leisure lists; every luxury brand; then region by region.
02 · EvidenceIndependent proof of quality
One inspection or expert signal (a MICHELIN Key, a Forbes rating, World's 50 Best, Condé Nast Traveler's Gold or Hot List, Relais & Châteaux), or two that corroborate each other (SLH or LHW, reader-voted awards, a respected publication's feature). A brand can support the case, never make it alone, and award lists help us find hotels, not decide.
03 · JudgmentLuxury, and a reason to choose it
Rooms, service, privacy, food and guiding at a level a demanding traveler would call luxury for that kind of place, and a specific reason to pick it over the region's benchmarks. A weaker version of a nearby hotel doesn't make the cut.
04 · PriceUS$400 a night or more
The price you'd actually pay for the entry room, two adults, on a dated high-season night, from the hotel first and booking sites second. The line is a commercial screen, not a measure of quality: a rare, documented exception is possible and is labeled. Where no reliable rate is published, we show an estimate from the prices we can see, marked to be confirmed.
05 · ChecksTracked separately
Open for 2026–27 and listed in official registries where they exist (Chile's SERNATUR, Peru's MINCETUR); bookable through travel advisors; and five years of news (fires, closures, lawsuits, owner changes), disclosed on the hotel's page. Each is its own check, apart from quality.